I only recommend products I love and I think you will, too. If you click on links I provide, I may receive a little compensation. Learn more.
best drugstore waterproof mascaras
According to my books, almost all women who wear makeup believe that stunning mascara and good lipstick are all they need to look good on no makeup days. And no doubt that almost all beauty gurus and bloggers around the world swear by good mascara. I believe a nice voluminous mascara completes the whole makeup look or just amps up your bare face.
While some may prefer washable mascaras, I’m all about waterproof mascaras, especially in summer when humidity and heat are bound to make your mascara run down the face and give you Panda eyes. And as much as we love a dewy glow, no one wants to end the day with panda eyes. I definitely don’t! And this is why I bring you the best drugstore waterproof mascaras you can use for summer and swimming and still end the day with pretty lush eyes.
Best drugstore waterproof mascaras
1. Maybelline lash sensational mascara
Maybelline knows its mascaras. I know this brand makes stunning drugstore makeup products, but mascaras are one thing they know, like the back of their hand. Rare are the chances that Maybelline mascaras will disappoint you.
I personally adore this drugstore waterproof mascara. I think it’s easily in my top 3 drugstore favorites. It fans out your lashes, doubles the volume, adds a natural curling effect (and if used with an eyelash curler, you’ll be blown!), and lengthens enough to give a falsies effect.
Also, its hybrid wand quickly gets through the inner and outer corners of your lashes without messing things up.
However, I have noticed that it starts to clump a little bit after 3-4 coats and dries up real soon, so you have to work fast with this. But that doesn’t bother me because, in 2 coats, I can get a pretty good volume and length that I never really need a third coat.
So for the price it comes with, I think it’s an absolute must-have drugstore waterproof mascara in your kit.
2. LO’real lash paradise mascara
There’s no going back from this waterproof mascara from Lo’real. It beautifully lengthens and volumizes your lashes simultaneously to make it look like you have false eyelashes on. And there is a very minimum chance that your mascara will clump, flake, or smudge. Just 2-3 coats can last you an entire day of rain or heat. But, it might feel a little bit sticky to some. And could clump your lashes after 3-4 coats.
Also, Lash paradise is known to be a famous makeup dupe for Too Faced better than sex mascara. I mean, that is a good reason to buy this one.
Overall, I really like this. I mean, it’s value for money and gives me stunning, uplifted eyelashes that last me all day.
Comparing my two favorites from Maybelline and LO’real, I found both of them equally good. Both are lengthening and volumizing mascaras with minimum clumps and flakes and both of them don’t smudge at all, even in water or while swimming (okay, they are waterproof after all). But, Maybelline’s lash sensational is a bit cheaper than Loreal lash paradise. So if both do the same job, why spend more money?
3. Maybelline sky high waterproof mascara
Known to be a dupe for Thrive Causemetics mascara, I absolutely LOVE this waterproof mascara. It lengthens your lashes like a dream that looks like you have falsies on. It was recently launched here, and you don’t know how much I wish I’d gotten my hands on it sooner.
Maybelline has some of the best affordable mascaras, and this one will definitely not be a miss. This Waterproof drugstore Mascara is perfect for creating long, full lashes that won’t flake or smudge. The lash extension brush features their exclusive flex tower mascara brush that bends to volumize and extend every single lash from root to tip.
Not only that, its unique formula gives your lashes full, lightweight coverage that’s perfect for a subtle or smokey look alike. Ophthalmologist and allergy tested, this waterproof mascara is also suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers.
So the sky’s the limit when it comes to dramatic lashes! You cannot go back from this stuff, and that is for sure.
4. Essence Lash Princess mascara
A mascara that defines and separates your lashes gorgeously? Oh yes, give me, give me! This one from Essence has been my cult favorite for ages. It provides a dramatic length to my lashes and adds the most beautiful volume (which I loveeee!) The best part? It does not budge at all. It just doesn’t. And is under $5. Trust me on this, you’ll not get a better price and quality anywhere else, you got to try this!
5. Maybelline hyper curl mascara
I told you, Maybelline knows its mascara. You can pick any of their best sellers with your closed eyes. And this one is another favorite of mine. I use it on days when I don’t have to put on heavy makeup. It’s not like it doesn’t work for heavy eyes, but it gives a very natural subtle appearance than a drastic one.
It’s super affordable, and as the name suggests, it locks up your lashes into a nice beautiful curve and lengthens them as well. It doesn’t have much volume but I think this waterproof mascara is quite good for everyday use.
6. LO’real volume million lashes mascara
Another super great mascara I can totally rave about. This million lashes mascara is just as pretty as the waterproof mascaras above and gives that fanned-out effect to the lashes and rarely clumps or smudges.
It has a beautiful wand that separates out each lash, and the consistency is not at all drying. They say it works best for sensitive eyes as well.
However, it needs more than 2-3 coats to achieve that look. You have to keep working on it, not much, but still, it’s not two coats and done kinda mascara. If that doesn’t bother you, it’s a pretty good drugstore waterproof mascara that you can add to your makeup routine.
For sunny and rainy days, it’s just the kind that will look expensive and voluminous but won’t drain out.
7. NYX Worth the hype mascara
Another one of the best drugstore mascaras out there, this one from NYX is more of a voluminous mascara than lengthening. It fluffs out your lashes really big. Does not flake or smudge. It can last up to 6-8 hours! And curls your lashes without a curler. It indeed is very creamy, so it will not dry your lashes; instead, feels very comfortable on your eyes and keeps them hydrated.
8. Maybelline Total Temptation mascara
This is quite a good drugstore waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes. It is a great volumizing mascara for fresh day events or night parties. As said, it does not clump, flake, or smudge. Plus, it has a delicious coconut-y smell to it. It is something I would take on a vacation with me.
Waterproof mascara FAQs
Is waterproof mascara better than regular mascara?
Now that depends on your preferences. If you feel like the mascara you are using smudges off your eyes or just doesn’t stay put, you definitely need to try some good waterproof mascaras then. But remember, since waterproof mascaras are little drying and may be best for summer or rainy season, it is not advisable for everyday use, or maybe, you want to look for waterproof mascaras with lash-conditioning properties.
Is it bad to wear waterproof mascaras?
Well, I don’t think so. Obviously, they are a bit too drying because they are meant to uphold your lashes the entire day, and the regular formula is not what will do that. You must use waterproof mascaras on alternate days and remove them very gently with some oil-based cleansers. DO NOT USE MAKEUP WIPES as they are surely gonna trigger pulling and tugging.
What are the best possible ways to remove waterproof mascaras?
Definitely, wet wipes are not the way to go. You need to massage an oil-based cleanser first. And leave it on for 20-30 seconds and gently remove it with cotton pads or whatever you prefer. Check out some DIY homemade makeup removers which are quite easy to make and cost you almost nothing. If that’s too much work for you, try these drugstore cleansing balms.
final thoughts on the best drugstore waterproof mascara
No matter what your beauty concerns are this summer, we hope these drugstore waterproof mascaras help you look and feel your best. They are totally worth the money and look amazing on the eyes. If I say that, I mean that, girl!
What drugstore waterproof mascara is your favorite? What have you used? What are you planning to buy? I want to know!!!
related articles to best drugstore waterproof mascaras
- 10 Literally The Best Drugstore Cleansing Balms
- 11 killer Makeup Products under $5
- Top 8 Drugstore Concealers to fake a night’s sleep